A Simply Excellent Solid Copper JHP: Asym .45 Auto 185gr TAC-XP Gel Test and Review

    As much as the curmudgeons favor it, .45 Auto has a dirty little secret: its typically low velocity often causes it to perform poorly in heavy clothing. Some bullets do perform well, but many fail to expand when fired through heavy clothing. Calibers such as 9mm Parabellum benefit from higher muzzle velocity when fired from a service pistol length barrel and that can somewhat make up for less than optimal bullet design.

     

     

    In this test, we find that the lighter weight bullet helps to achieve higher velocity, which in turn, helps to achieve reliable expansion in heavy clothing. Were this a lead core bullet, that lower mass and consequently lower sectional density might also lead to inadequate penetration, especially when fired into bare gel. It’s a difficult balance to strike: reliable expansion in heavy clothing and adequate penetration in bare gel. That’s because, if a bullet expands more readily, then it also slows down more quickly. Conversely, if heavy clothing delays expansion or reduces the degree of expansion, it reduces the amount of drag the bullet experiences, which of course increases penetration.

     

    Bare gel

    Bare gel

     

    Bare gel

    Bare gel

     

    But as it turns out, the performance produced by this bullet was almost identical in both cases. There was less than 2″ of variation between the shallowest bullet and the deepest. Likewise, expansion occurred almost instantly. The four layers of denim do not appear to have delayed expansion at all.

     

    Heavy clothing

    Heavy clothing

     

    Heavy clothing

    Heavy clothing

     

    The measurements bear out this consistent performance, and frankly, this is no great surprise. Solid copper hollow points have a reputation for producing almost boring repeatability and this test supports that reputation. The ammunition was loaded very consistently, with an extreme spread of only 26fps and the bullet held up its end with consistent penetration, weight retention, and expansion. While there may be some debate about the real world usefulness of sharp edges, it certainly can’t hurt performance and these bullets toss that in as a cherry on top of virtually text book performance in every other regard.

    recovered bullets

    recovered bullets

    Velocities in feet per second:

    1,027
    1,010
    1,023
    1,001
    1,012
    Average: 1,014.60
    StdDev: 10.45
    Min: 1,001
    Max: 1,027
    Spread: 26

    Bare gel measurements:
    Penetration: 14.2″, 16.6″
    Retained weight: 185.0gr, 184.5gr
    Max expansion: 0.815″, 0.797″
    Min expansion: 0.449″, 0.446″

    Heavy clothing measurements:
    Penetration: 13.9″, 14.5″
    Retained weight: 184.7gr, 185.0gr
    Max expansion: 0.815″, 0.777″
    Min expansion: 0.451″, 0.448″

     

    Many THANKS to:

    Proxibid: Shop For Home Defense Pistols Online Here
    http://goo.gl/Mw54uT

    Ventura Munitions: http://bit.ly/1LKxNRP
    Please Support Them! They help make our videos possible.

    Hoppe’s No. 9 Gun Bore Cleaner: A favorite since 1903
    http:// www.hoppes.com

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Also, check out our Patreon page if you enjoy our program, and consider helping us at TFBTV out!
    https://www.patreon.com/tfbtv

    Andrew

    Andrew is a combat veteran of OEF and has performed hundreds of ballistic tests for his YouTube channel, The Chopping Block (https://www.youtube.com/user/chopinbloc). He is an avid firearm collector and competitor and lives with his family in Arizona. If you have any questions, you may email him at [email protected]


    Advertisement