We have tested several 9mm defense loads from a 3.1″ S&W Shield and none of them have done very well. Even the Federal 9mm 150gr HST that is specifically marketed for short barrel pistols had less than ideal performance. It’s a difficult trick to design a bullet that can expand well and penetrate adequately while still being able to expand when fired through heavy clothing, and do all of that at the relatively low velocities produced by short barrel 9mm pistols. If you reduce weight, you can get higher velocity, which can improve expansion, but that reduced weight can result in shallower penetration too.
So when we tested Federal 9mm +P 124gr HST, I was unsure of what to expect. To say that it’s a well respected load in service pistol length barrels is a bit of an understatement. It is quite probably the best possible load and it’s been very well documented. But given the track record of other 9mm in the short barrel, I was prepared for less than perfect results and I was pleasantly surprised.
Recoil is, of course, a bit snappier than standard pressure 124gr 9mm, but it’s by no means obnoxious. Velocity was decent for a 3.1″ barrel.
In bare gel, the figures and appearance of the bullet and the wound track are all textbook. Everything is as near perfect as can be.
Penetration: 14.9″, 16.0″
Retained weight: 122.9gr, 123.9gr
Max expansion: 0.638″, 0.663″
Min expansion: 0.414″, 0.405″
But that is the easy part. Many bullets can produce decent results in bare gel, even at short barrel velocities. The hard part is being able to do that in heavy clothing as well. In this case, the results were not quite perfect. But they were nevertheless very good. Penetration was a little deep and expansion was somewhat more moderate. But expansion did occur and it was both reliable and uniform. Bear in mind that this is also the IWBA four layers of denim standard, not the FBI heavy clothing. The latter is a bit easier to pass.
Penetration: 19.1″, 19.4″
Retained weight:123.8gr, 123.5gr
Max expansion: 0.635″, 0.675″
Min expansion: 0.393″, 0.386″
I may sound as if I’m gushing a bit, but this is really the best set of results seen so far from a short barrel pistol. If it means anything, I did switch from Speer’s short barrel +P 124gr Gold Dot to 124gr HST in my own Shield.
Buy it at Ventura Munitions:
Guns in this video:
S&W Shield 9mm
Many THANKS to:
Proxibid: Shop For Home Defense Pistols Online Here
Ventura Munitions: http://bit.ly/1LKxNRP
Please Support Them! They help make our videos possible.
Hoppe’s No. 9 Gun Bore Cleaner: A favorite since 1903
Also, check out our Patreon page if you enjoy our program, and consider helping us at TFBTV out!