Breast Implants Stop Bullet

800px_ruptured_implant-tfb

NBC LA reports

Carranza was just a few feet away. She survived a gunshot to the chest, but the the bullet left a scar and deflated the implant.

“She’s just one lucky woman,” Dr. Ashkan Ghavami told the LA Times. “I saw the CT scan. The bullet fragments were millimeters from her heart and her vital organs. Had she not had the implant, she might not be alive today.”

Something does not seem right about this story. I wonder if she hit by just a fragment. I would imagine that the hydrostatic shock from a bullet ripping through a gel implant would have a devastating impact on the surrounding tissue.

A ruptured Silicon gel implant. Photo from Wikipedia.

Gentlemen: please be considerate and don’t drive away my female readers away with jokes at their expense!

[ Many thanks to jdun1911 for emailing me the link. ]

Related

Steve Johnson

Founder and Dictator-In-Chief of TFB. A passionate gun owner, a shooting enthusiast and totally tacti-uncool. Favorite first date location: any gun range. Steve can be contacted here.


More In: Ammunition, News


Advertisement

  • Royi

    It’s not clear what kind of bullet it was, but it basically sounds as if the implants are reacting like a dilatant (wich viscosity increases under stress).

    Wich actually doesn’t surprise me since the fluids used in the last generation silicone implants and the liquid armor research have similar properties.

  • http://blog.mrcia.se/ Brooks

    I doubt that hydrostatic shock would be much of a factor in taking a hit like the one described. Breasts are almost entirely “made” from very soft and elastic tissue resulting in the force from any shock simply dissipating in the surrounding tissue. And since there are no major blood vessels on the outside of the ribcage remote shock is similarly reduced in severity if not, as I would suspect, completely eliminated.

  • CinSC

    I see a new test for the Box’OTruth. ;)

  • SpudGun

    If you actually read the article, the surgeon said that the implant didn’t have any impact on stopping the bullet. Sounds like someone just trying to cash in on this adverted tragedy.

  • Matt Groom

    You wouldn’t believe it, but this kind of thing acutally happens all the time. It happened a few years ago in Orlando. Stripper is harassed by creepy guy in club. She complains, he gets kicked out. Later, he meets her in the parking lot and SHOOTS her in the chest (I can’t remember what caliber). She goes down, he runs away. She survives, because the bullet is deflected by her breast implant.

    Breast Implants have also been shown to act as a Breast Cancer reducer, since the body’s immune system remains on a “high alert” mode trying to destroy the alien entity. I speculate that this might mean that there would be a reduced chance of infection from such an injury should medical care not be readily available. It makes one wonder about using silicon implants as a kind of permanent body armor.

    Also, there’s no such thing as “Hydrostatic Shock” since liquids do not exist in stasis (static state) during such an event (moving in a wave after the impact). The proper term for this phenomena seems to be “Hydrodynamic shock”. See here: http://www.rathcoombe.net/sci-tech/ballistics/myths.html#energy

  • Don

    From the article it sounds like the implant helped to fragment and slow the bullet rather than stopping it all together.

    “The bullet fragments were millimeters from her heart and her vital organs.”

    Would be interesting to know the caliber.

    -D

  • Trent

    Well, that’s it, I’m buying the biggest pair I can for the wife. For her safety, you know.

  • Jon Mac

    How could hydrostatic shock in the gel cause damage to the tissue around it?

    • http://www.thefirearmblog.com Steve

      Jon, the shock would transfer.

  • HK_WSU

    This sounds like a possible topic for Mythbusters.

  • Lance

    Proof you need to have your girlfriend/wife get implants make them safe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Kyle Huff

    Female readers? LOL!

    • http://www.thefirearmblog.com Steve

      Kyle, actually there are! I wish I had more but don’t really know how to attract them.

  • Maigo

    Wouldn’t any large breast stop the bullet the same?
    Doesn’t seem like under penetration so much as a lack of over penetration.

    I guess the moral of the story is, if you’re attacked by a really fat guy, shoot controlled pairs

  • http://www.practicalgunreview.blogspot.com practicalgunreview

    Awesome. Try selling this concept to the wife!

  • Meltron

    Ahh, breast implants saving the day!

  • Valhalla

    Must have been a bad shot. For me to believe that one of those could stop a bullet (any word on the size? And yes, it is a legitimate question) the round would have had to hit on or near the middle, not really where I would aim if trying to kill someone.

  • Cameron

    hmmm now if they were only backed with kevlar……..

  • Jim

    there are so many variables in this it’s hard to really quantify if the implant really did stop the bullet.. was the implant above, or below the pectoral muscle?? how thick was the casing on the implant?? what type of round was shot?? what angle??

    the thing is, the woman survived the shooting, which is what really matters..

  • jdun1911

    I don’t see how it is a bad shot. The bullet hit her in the chest.

    Here the thing there is no such thing as one shot stop. It is a myth and I stated here many times.

  • Jared

    Fwd To: Wife

  • Valhalla

    jdun, the problem is because of graphic nature we’re never going to get more pictures. I would assume a man (if a man shot her) would be taller, and would be shooting down (at least some). I would then expect the round to hit her a bit higher, unless the shot was taken before a full sight picture. Sorry I missed your comments concerning one shot stop.

  • jdun1911

    Lance been in four gun fights. In those fights he has been shot many times.

    http://rpginn.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1072&Itemid=39

    The Miami Shoot out. The second most famous gun fight between law enforcement and two heavy armed criminals. They were shot multiple of times, outnumber 4 to 1, and was able to killed 2 FBI agents and injured five.

    http://www.thegunzone.com/11april86.html

    Guy got shot in the head and survive.

    http://www.ohio.com/news/top_stories/37369379.html

    22 hits, 17 in the chest and five minute after the last shot fired he expired.

    http://www.lawofficer.com/news-and-articles/articles/lom/0412/the_peter_soulis_incident.html

    nascar3n8fa an AR15 member got shot three times in a gun fight but able to drive back the the attacker.

    http://www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=984615

    His after action report.

    http://www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=988015&sr=0

    I could go on but you’ll get the idea.

  • Matt Groom

    Under high stress situations, people tend to point shoot. In point shooting, at close ranges, you tend to hit what you were staring at.

  • guntotin_fool

    frankly, this is not surprising at all, the newer silicone gels being used in the implants has a very high surface tension, and fairly low viscosity, to allow for proper texture/feel and to prevent any of the gel from migrating through the body if the implant ruptures These two qualities are also the same as those being looked at in the liquid body armor tests. Also, depending on the size (area) of the implant, the amount of energy expended to the body would be dissipated down to fraction of the PSI that the bullet would have delivered on its own.

  • Sam Suggs

    probobly a 22lr holowpoint or somthing of the sort